Closing The Conservation Gap In Electric Power
Topics: oil, energy industry, renewable resources, natural resources, CERA, energy conservation
Today, as U.S. electric power demand grows and environmental and energy security issues become more urgent, there is a growing concern that the current balance encourages the construction of new power plants rather than investment in the conservation of electric power.
This subject is coming to the fore, in part, because of the capacity challenges that the electric power industry will start facing in the next few years. But at least as important is that conservation is coming to the top of the agenda across the U.S. economy-an emphasis that has not been seen for decades.
That, in turn, forces us to focus on the dynamics of conservation or, as it is also called, energy efficiency. Most industry observers agree that there is indeed a “power conservation investment gap” in the U.S. But the gap does not exist for the reasons most people think.
Misperceptions about the reasons behind the conservation gap lead to a focus on the wrong set of fixes and set unrealistic expectations. To close the gap, we must first address these misperceptions and identify the gap’s real causes.
The first misperception is that power conservation potential has hardly been tapped. The reality is quite different-a great deal of power conservation has already occurred. The U.S. has slowly but steadily reduced its electric intensity-the amount of power used per unit of economic output-over the past two decades.
Overall, the weather-normalized electric intensity of the U.S. economy has declined 18 percent since the mid-1980s. And most of these efficiency gains occurred during a period when the real price of power was steadily declining.
The cumulative effect is quite dramatic-if the U.S. consumed electricity with the same intensity it did in 1987, its power system today would need the daily operation of additional power supply equal in size to the combined power systems of Texas and California.
Misperception Number Two is that conservation and efficiency are free-that the benefits to consumers and producers far outweigh the costs-and that cost is not an issue. But conservation is not just a matter of switching off lamps and turning thermostats down in winter and up in summer. Substantial and sustained power conservation involves real effort and requires real up-front investment and ongoing costs.
Misperception Number Three is that power users underinvest in conservation because they are chronically ill-informed about its benefits. Due to this view, the most common public policy solution for conservation underinvestment today is funding consumer education programs.
Yet the concept that households make poor decisions when it comes to conservation simply does not square with observed data on consumer behavior. Over the past several decades, the statistical evidence is quite compelling-power consumers act quite rationally and in an informed manner by consistently responding to real increases in power prices by consuming less. Last year was a good example.
Consumers responded to some of the biggest price increases they have seen in quite some time by reducing their consumption of electricity. As a result, power demand stayed flat, even though inflation-adjusted economic growth exceeded 3 percent on the year.
Misperception Number Four is that power engineers are just genetically conditioned toward building big and advanced power plants rather than pursuing small and beautiful conservation options. This idea stems from the perception that if cost-effective conservation potential exists, then power producers should naturally invest in conservation rather than production.
Yet when power producers actually do invest in conservation, they find it hard to pay for the investment because the benefits naturally flow to the consumers who end up using less power.
So even if regulators do allow producers to treat these investments the same way they treat production investments-allowing these costs onto the balance
sheet as the basis for approved cost recovery-the effect is that higher costs must be recovered from a smaller base of sales. In order to break even, the producer needs a price increase. And that is something customers and politicians typically resist. And this represents the current best case for producers.
Most states do not provide such cost recovery, and no state in the U.S. has put together a regulatory and incentive package that encourages power producers to seek the proper balance of conservation and production investments.
Although the conventional wisdom concerning power conservation underinvestment may not be accurate and current policy is lacking, there are nevertheless real reasons to expect a conservation gap. Power deregulation has created bigger and more liquid wholesale power markets that express the cost of power at any point in time. One lesson from the emergence of power markets is clear: the cost of electricity varies considerably through time and is often well above the price that most customers face.
This is especially true during peak periods of power demand when the cost of electric production (and conversely the value of conservation) is many times higher than the prices customers are being charged. This is intentional-consumers, regulators and politicians want stable and predictable power prices that do not reflect the cost of power during its most expensive times.
It is not surprising that these stakeholders work together to fetter wholesale prices with price caps and disconnect retail power prices from costs with a variety of mechanisms in order to make them less volatile and more predictable. The net result is that the prices customers see are often lower than the costs of the power they are consuming.
Customers invest in conservation based on the retail prices they face. Yet, it is the more volatile cost of power that determines how much conservation is truly cost effective. When confronted with typical retail prices instead of the costs of power, consumers quite sensibly invest in some but not all of the cost effective conservation. The unintended consequence of this well-intended retail price regime is the continuing underinvestment in power conservation from the consumer side.
From this perspective, the root cause of the power conservation investment gap is not an uneducated consumer but rather an informed consumer rationally responding to the prices they face.
The implication is clear: there is a very real electric power conservation gap, and it is on the consumer side of the power sector. Further, the simple fix of confronting consumers with real-time power prices is not desirable. There are very good reasons not to have grandmothers living on social security paying real power costs to keep their air conditioners going in August. Therefore, if the objective is to have power producers invest in the cost effective conservation that consumers do not invest in, then regulatory policies must create a set of incentives for them to do so.
Although some attempts have been made, so far, no state in the U.S. has created a structure that gives power producers sufficient incentive to close the conservation gap. With the renewed focus on energy efficiency, the time is right to meet the challenge and close the conservation gap in order to balance the investment playing field between new power plants and
conservation.
Doing so will certainly not eliminate the need for new power plants in the future. But it will reduce power plant requirements, lessen price increases, create environmental benefits, increase energy security and create greater incentives for long-term research and development in efficiency.
Daniel Yergin, chairman of CERA, received the Pulitzer Prize for “The Prize: The Epic Quest for Oil, Money & Power” and the United States Energy Award for lifelong achievements in energy and the promotion of international understanding. Vist CERA at cera.ecnext.com.
Previous Articles Highlighter:
Financial Aid Search Terms And 2 Cool Programs To Get An Early Start (1)
Topics: financial aid search, money for college, FAFSA, 529, education IRA Preparing for college this fall or in a couple of years? The list below covers basic terms and a couple of programs you should know about.
How Much Oil Is Really Down There? Oil And Gas Reserves Accounting Needs Updating (2)
The current system also insists on using year-end prices to calculate whether oil and gas reserves count as "economic" and thus as proved, rather than some kind of average. But this is no sure guide either to what happened during the year or to what will happen in the coming year-or even to what happened on that particular day.
Ethanol And Brazil: The New Global Energy Brand? (3)
After 2000, stimulated by rising oil prices and a new initiative by the government to encourage consumption of renewable fuels, the Brazilian automotive industry began to produce vehicles that could run on either ethanol or gasoline in any proportion.
Free Home Foreclosure Listing: Valuable Information? (4)
This may make a free home foreclosure listing look like an easier alternative. But even with a free listing, you will have to browse through the countless national listings to find listings in your area.
A Double Bubble Drives Rising Oil Production Costs (5)
What has received far less attention is another increase: the parallel rise in the costs of drilling for oil and building the infrastructure necessary to pump it out of the ground.
Texas Auto Insurance Is A Necessity According To The Laws Of Texas (6)
An Insurance Broker Can Provide Necessary Help You can also source Texas auto insurance by availing of the services of an insurance broker who will help you explore all the available avenues, and help you compare different insurance policies and rates as well.
How To Avoid VA Home Foreclosure (7)
A VA home foreclosure can be devastating not only to the homeowner's emotional well being but to their finances as well. If something is not done to stop the foreclosure process, they know all too well that they can lose your home and ruin their chances of buying another home.
Should You Buy A Foreclosure Home ? (8)
Just be sure to research the property for potential repair issues before you buy a foreclosure home. www.TheForeclosureInfoSite.com brings you information on many different types of foreclosures. There's nothing to buy just real information for real people.Check us out today at www.TheForeclosureInfoSite.com
Why So Many Women Are Beginning To Wear Men's Shoes (9)
Many women can't afford to pay that for shoes, which is why they may consider just buying men's shoes. They might feel a little embarrassed, and definitely make sure no one is looking when they try the shoes on, but for them such an alternative is a lot better than having to get overpriced custom shoes.
College Applications: Never Too Early To Start (10)
Submitting your application early may also help out in terms of how it's processed by prospective colleges. As mentioned above, one of the most important features of your application is the application essay.
Newer Articles Highlighter:
China And America Need Not Be Energy Rivals (1)
The real risks are not from competition in the global marketplace. Rather they would arise when oil and gas development gets caught up in larger foreign policy issues, of which those involving Iran and Sudan are currently the most obvious.
The Benefits Of Tornado Insurance (2)
Tornados are covered under the wind event listing. The best way to know for certain if you are covered for this is to look at your policy. It is very important for those individuals who live in what is commonly called tornado alley to review their policies.
Smart Phones Are More Personal (3)
A smart phone is a full-featured mobile phone that comes equipped with the personal computer like functionality.So it is the most efficient way of being mobile and carrying your office with you.
What Does 'Energy Security' Really Mean? (4)
A second, urgent need is to bring China and India into the energy security system. There is much talk of a clash between the United States and China over oil.
Making Your Home Business More Profitable (5)
Get the word out and you will draw in more customers to increase profits through sales. Get Creative/ Be Adventurous Do not be afraid to think outside the box, to sample creative techniques.
Gift Ideas For Every Occasions (6)
Many times the gift you buy ends up in the garage or seeks another home rather than the person it is meant for and all the efforts put into buying the gift seem useless.
Hurghada Holidays In Egypt - Discover Seashore Resort (7)
Makadi Bay, a dreamy beachside resort, just 35 km south of Hurghada has many beach resorts providing a location for scuba diving and snorkeling. Most hotels in Hurghada are located in a 20 km long strip parallel to the beach; they range from 5 star or 4 star luxury accommodations to traditional and simple Egyptian guesthouses.
An Irrational Fear For A White Board (8)
The only thing I now have to worry about is my fear of getting another phobia (phobophobia). Teaching expert Catherine Harvey looks at interactive white boards as a teaching tool.
Water Gardening Pump - 8 Amazing Tips Regarding A Water Gardening Pump! (9)
Here the costs should cover initial amount, electricity costs, and maintenance. Each manufacturer would have given a set of instructions with each pump. Go through them and decide which pump falls within your budget.
Provide Your Offerings In The Right Places (10)
The company could have overcome this problem by moving to a smaller inexpensive site in the same town that was more desirable to customers. If that wasn't possible, the company should have offered a service to pick up, straighten, and return rims during the evenings when customers are at home.