Anticipating The Market And Execution
Keywords: forex,trading,money,exchange,currency,investment,fund,foreign,market,stock,trend,dollar,global
I divide trading skills into two distinct elements: anticipating the market and execution. The anticipating part is reading the market, whether through charts, systems, technical indicators or intuition. Anticipating/reading the market is the trading skill that most of us focus all our energy on, and it is the subject covered by most trading books and seminars.
The execution part, meaning the actual trading part, is an often overlooked skill of trading. A good way to clarify the distinction between being able to anticipate the market and being able to effectively execute the trades is to describe the difference between the brokers and the locals on the floor of the exchange. (In Europe the floor no longer exists as all trading is now electronic).
Locals on the floor are independent traders trading for their own account (profit). Their motivation is (like ours) to make money and their preoccupation is (like ours) to be able to anticipate the market. The job of brokers on the floor is to execute orders from traders not on the floor. These orders may be from bank traders trading in an office or independent traders trading from home.
Ruthlessly efficient
Either way these orders are generated from somewhere ‘off the floor’ and they need to be executed ‘on the floor’ by a broker. So what makes a good broker? Think about what you would want from a broker. You would want someone who executes your trades with the utmost efficiency i.e, no hesitating, no indecisiveness, no coyness.
A broker needs to be sharp and alert to what is happening in the market so that they are always in a position to immediately execute any trade that they are given. A good floor broker is a joy to watch, they are ruthlessly efficient. They can go from idly chatting in a quiet market, to disseminating an endless flow of orders in a busy one.
Now imagine having to trade through a broker. What would it be like trading through a novice broker? Someone who doesn’t know one end of an order from another. Not a pleasant prospect! Now imagine what it would be like trading with a highly skilled and experienced broker… Quite a different experience I think you will agree.
Anticipation and execution
Locals have to both anticipate the market and execute their own trades. If you think of all the possible combinations:
- Good anticipation / poor execution,
- Poor anticipation / poor execution,
- Good anticipation / good execution,
- Poor anticipation / good execution,
It is obvious which we would all rather be, good / good; but which combination would you say you are? I suspect there are a lot of good anticipation/poor execution traders out there who lose money despite their anticipation skills. So not only do we need good anticipation skills we also need good execution skills to succeed in trading. We need to develop the attitude of a broker when it comes to the task of actually executing our trades.
A broker is judged by his execution skills. It does not matter to a broker whether the trade he has just executed for a client is profitable or not. The broker, his boss and his client are only concerned with his ability to execute the trade efficiently.
So a broker gets to fulfill his need to be successful, to be a winner, by doing his job efficiently and effectively. That is all we can ask of a broker, it would be crazy to hold him responsible for the outcome of the trade. Going back to my earlier analogy of the trading floor, a local trader, on the other hand, is responsible for the outcome of his trades.
The local is trying to make money by anticipating the market. So a local has to decide whether it is a good time to buy or sell and then execute the trade. He is doing two things, deciding when to trade and then executing the trade. A local therefore has two aspects of his trading to judge, the accuracy of his market anticipation and the execution of his trades.
Poor execution or anticipation?
We know that trading is a numbers game, i.e. our success is not dependent on the outcome of the next trade; our success is dependent on the overall profitability of many trades. So while we are trading, whether the last trade we did was profitable or not is not important; there is no point drawing conclusions on the outcome of just one, or even a few trades.
We can only access our anticipation skills when we have made a reasonable number of trades and we can see the longer-term result of our actions. This contemplation is best made when we are not trading, when that markets are closed or when we are taking a break. When the markets are open and we are engaged in trading, the only thing it is appropriate to judge is our execution skill.
When we are trading our goal should be to focus on executing our trades with ruthless efficiency and to judge only that. If you consider the ways that you lose money trading, I think you will find that it is down to poor execution, rather than poor anticipation.
Appraise and amend
- You fail to place a stop loss according to your predetermined loss limits,
- You place a stop loss but then move it as the market approaches,
- You hesitate and miss an opportunity that you had clearly seen,
- You trade out of frustration or anger,
- You fail to use a trailing stop to protect your profit,
- You let a winning trade turn into a losing trade etc.
All the above (and there are more) fall into the category of poor execution rather than poor market anticipation. So if you want to turn your trading round, or make it more profitable, then cut out the above mistakes by focusing all your energy on executing your trades. Only judge yourself, when trading, on your execution. You can appraise and amend your strategy/approach when the markets are closed.
Martin Chandra (martinchandra.com) is a full-time investor. He has been researching investment strategies and make his own living. For more information please go to martinchandra.com
Previous Articles Highlighter:
What Is Support And Resistance (1)
Consequently when a trend line of long duration, which has been successfully tested many times, has been violated then an important reversal of trend has likely occurred. However, on no account exit the market until definitive evidence of trend termination has occurred.
How To Change Careers... When You're Not Qualified (2)
Couldn't you present yourself as someone with unequalled business experience, skills and knowledge - someone who has built and sold a company, as opposed to someone with theoretical knowledge acquired from a business school?
How To Decide On A Fashion Design School (3)
To ensure that you are able to truly develop your abilities you must therefore find a school that focuses on your own field of specialization. You need to consider the overall Curriculum which the school offers.
How To Make Web Surfing Secure (4)
You will want this file to contain your checklist of things to do everyday before you start surfing the Internet. So far, we've uncovered some interesting facts about web surfing.
Exiting A Losing Trade (5)
I don't however recommend it to new traders simply because they get whipsawed too much. A stop loss is the level at which you will close a trade on the basis that it has gone too far in the 'wrong' direction, and therefore negated the reason for being in that trade.
What Is Open Source Software And Why Is It Used? (6)
- In a 2002 survey it was found over 31% of UK and nearly 42% of German companies were using or planning to use OSS. - In 2001, Debian (an Open Source Operating System), contained over 55 million lines of code and was estimated to have consumed over 14,000 person years in development time.
Advertising Tips For A Network Marketing Business (7)
There once was a time when having sufficient keywords listed in meta tags would draw their attention but the number of hits to websites with erroneous information led search engine developers to train their spiders to look for only good information.
Securing The Lowest Home Mortgage Rate (8)
The more you can put down, the better. If your down payment is high enough, it's possible you will find your mortgage rate will be less. This, however, is not the biggest factor that's looked at for banks.
A Striking Domain Name Could Be The Key To Success (9)
The easier it is for potential customers to find your site and remember its name, the better. As you do a domain name search, you're likely to find getting into the process isn't as easy as you might have expected.
Low Mortgage Rates Can Be Had (10)
It also means ensuring that you have a good mix of credit - revolving loans, regular loans, such as auto loans, and so on. In addition to making your payments, it's important not to have too much credit.
Newer Articles Highlighter:
High Low Breakout Technique (1)
"DR" is daily range, "TH-YH" is today's high minus yesterday's high and "YL-TL" is yesterday's low minus today's low. In the "TH-YH" column, I only record an entry if today's high is greater than yesterday's high and in the "YL-TL" I only record an entry if today's low is lower than yesterday's low.
What Is Simple Moving Average? (2)
In the last example we have three MAs 4, 9 and 18. These help represent the short, medium and long term trend. When the 4 and 9 period moving average cross we have a potential buy or sell signal.
Where To Place Your Trading Stop (3)
You may find that by using this method you are taken out to frequently only to find the market taking off in the direction of the original trade. The best way to overcome this is to do some back testing to find the best amount for the market you are trading.
The Mastery Of Self Trading (4)
My baby son Arthur, does not yet know that touching a hot stove is painful. At some point he will burn himself and he will start to form a set of beliefs about hot things that will, by governing his behaviour, protect him from getting burnt.
Day Trading Strategy (5)
Reading Gary Smiths book "How I trade for a living", I came across a reference to an interview with Donald Sliter, a top S&P floor trader. When asked about his trading strategy he had replied that it is a matter of understanding strength and weakness.
How To Lose Weight By Avoiding The Triggers To Weight Gain? (6)
Armed with the information about your eating habits, you can now plan your new eating pattern so that you can better achieve your weight loss goals. For example, if you find that you're eating an extra meal because you're feeling hungry between the main meals, you could plan a snack in between.
Intraday Trading Tactics (7)
I also like to see the low of day 3 tested in some way. As you can see from the chart the low was made then the market made some progress upward and then came back down to near the newly formed low where it found support (buyers).
The Trend Is Your Friend (8)
Just think about it, if anyone one had an exact method that always won, they would have all the money in the world, given enough time. Lets discus this a little further.
The Flaw In Our Emotions (9)
- Much success can be attributed to inactivity. Most investors cannot resist the temptation to constantly buy and sell. - Lethargy, bordering on sloth should remain the cornerstone of an investment style.
What Are Commonly Traded Securities (10)
Trades are executed through phone and increasingly through the Internet. It is only in the last few years that the smaller investor has been able to gain access to this market.